ARCADIA-Studio/harness/STATE.md

Progress Ledger — first release

Updated 2026-09-11, Codex-9e8r6t /root, Windows host. Release remains unaccepted; meaningful product and integration work is active.

Objective and current source

Deliver the complete OA/SA first release in PROJECT_GOAL.md. The latest authoritative attachment is 815ff7b9-73c4-41a2-a809-635ecf8389d6/goal-objective.md, read in full and preserved in that file. It requires constraints/calculations, quantities/units and reusable libraries, plus uncluttered human/AI text-only modeling at small and large scale. Long homogeneous lists and poor behavior editing remain explicit concerns.

Local branch: codex/release1-9e8r6t, base 1797516, committed head 4bb4aaf. Named behavior creation, its guide and independent oracle, concise text-first examples and prior integration evidence are committed and remotely transferred. Its final ancestry/guide correction passed full653; post-lint history63, strict Clippy/fmt and matching GUI build passed. Current uncommitted work corrects the oracle's retained-file rule, clarifies source-7 constructor defaults, records native creation and implements contextual prerequisite creation. Preserve all workers' edits. No open Gitea PRs at the latest read, comments through138.

Completed work and scoped evidence

• Palette inline naming and focused Escape: 7d1df4f, independently published as codex/palette-authoring-20260910. Candidate 2 focused tests, GUI build and strict desktop Clippy passed. Its native F2 rename/Save/Undo/Redo matched exact three-file expectations; Entity creation matched the complete independent model/source oracle. Candidate3 completed ordinary Activity, existing placement, allocation, direct Interaction and F2: complete basic model/four sources PASS. Explicit SA actor/destination transition passed complete model/six sources; Undo four-source baseline, Redo six-source result and reopen all passed. Six physical files are byte-identical across reopen/reuse-preview Cancel/Save. Immutable checkpoints/logs: .local/native-qa/palette-20260910-v3/.
• Recovery naming autofocus: 31b7dc3, 13 focused checkpoint tests passed after integrated compilation. Its new autofocus behavior still needs native check.
• Other-host behavior/topology/scenario/history: original 01bb52a integrated as 057eddd; constructor cache fix b6b76ef integrated as a70de55; explicit history seed fix 4ecad78 cherry-picked as 81668f9.
• Corrected immutable desktop artifact completed 631/631 passed,408.18s, exit0; all three prior618-artifact failures are fixed. Exact artifact/logs in .local/scenario-workspace-20260910/tests-81668f9/. It covers3978bbe workspace, Back/OpenUse guards and both history fixes, but not later Sensor/creation work.
• A real same-size owner/document Sensor regression led to d114a27; affected scenario53/53 passed. Current native candidate3 predates that correction. Mounted workspace tests cover500×570 and wide geometry; native current-build scenario acceptance remains pending.
• Named local creation passed final21/21 and guide3/3 after ancestry-label correction. The matching immutable desktop suite passed 653/653,362.83s, zero failures/ignored; exact artifact864B0F…E86/log/result under .local/behavior-creation-20260911/tests-final. Independent integration review found no additional correctness blocker. StrictClippy/all-targets/-Dwarnings and workspacefmt pass after one behavior-equivalent history_fields let-chain correction; affected history63/63 and matching GUI rebuild pass. Current native GUI is gui-verified SHA D4D9C2BD…B20C31. At actual 1100×700 client size, named OA Process, explicit ParticipantInteraction Scenario with capability context and SA owner-linked State machine plus requested first view passed complete independent Project/SourceBundle checks at 7/8/9 files. Each single Undo/Redo preserved exact expected semantics, sources and role identities. Reopen/Save retained all nine physical source files byte-for-byte. Wide/minimum draft cancellations retained the initial six files exactly. Detailed report: native creation.
• Independent creation oracle v2 corrects a harness assumption: Save retains known detached source files after Undo. Full Project and reachable source equality remain mandatory; the complete physical inventory must equal the explicit pre-Undo checkpoint overlaid with expected reachable bytes. Unknown, changed or missing retained files fail. No product defect was hidden by this correction; see oracle review.
• Fresh source-7 constructor probes passed 54 explicit/omitted comparisons and 12 required-field refusals across OA/SA, with complete typed models, canonical reparse and exact authored no-op/name-edit retention. Constructor and Scenario default wording now describes current behavior; strict HTML regeneration passed. Other constructor families are explicitly outside this evidence. See default review.
• Source schema checks passed: 72 fixtures, 204 schemas, 14 families, 90 scalar leaves. API/language reST rendered with strict docutils without warnings.
• Packaging committed b98f135: portable Linux adapter, shared package checks, Docker input validation and exact upstream notices. Independent review found and fixed five concrete defects. Python 11/11 and PowerShell contracts pass. Historical Windows-input ZIP has 557 files; real Linux notices close over 339 packages/681 files. Linux archive adapter used inert ELF fixtures, not actual current application binaries. Exact Fira/Cantarell notice Git bytes were independently verified. Current-source notices need regeneration.
• Independent native Capella creation study completed, saved and closed cleanly; report release-capella-creation-study-20260910.md is complete. Viewpoint-first naming and distinct local create/existing selection inform the implementation.
• Textual usability audit completed three static tasks and example counts. The existing grammar already permits omitted initial IDs/defaults; key gaps are cross-file reference context, safe alias refactoring and reviewed patches. Source7 EBNF/schema documentation and viewpoint omission guidance are corrected; generated language HTML passed strict docutils. Both concise snippets passed 26 real REST requests: identity-only stabilization, exact no-op/name edit, stale/invalid nonmutation and restart persistence. All120 current core/server files match the preserved source7 binary's documented snapshot. This closes the bounded recipe gap, not large-model or native text-editor acceptance. The verified recipe is now examples/text-first and in the language reference.

Detailed evidence: integrated gates, palette native, scenario workspace, creation design, packaging implementation, independent packaging review.

Active ownership and execution

• Root: integration, common ledgers, source/API checks and exclusive native input. Full653 is terminal PASS. V4 creation/Undo/Redo/reopen is complete; actual SA pending-draft crash recovery is active on the same verified GUI. The forced interruption targeted only isolated QA PID5184 after checkpoint persistence; restarted PID1284/window6161106 uses the same private profile and runtime. Recovery is now terminal PASS: full draft fields/IDs retained, autofocus, first Escape and a fresh Save As preserve the complete nine-file model. The current wide GUI is saved on checkpoint-recovery-cancel/project.arcadia; treat that checkpoint as immutable and reopen a work copy before editing.
• release_audit: prior creation and constructor reports frozen. Now owns the staged prerequisite creation implementation for Scenario Lifeline/process Work/ New machine owner, semantic first-action prompts, relevant App/recovery/guide wiring and focused tests. Cargo writer is reserved to this worker when needed; freeze source during tests and request independent review before integration.
• behavior_audit: v2 native oracle frozen, warnings-denied compilation and falsifiers pass, executable056EEFD…F6A36. Now independently challenges staged source semantics and expected behavior; no production/Cargo/native ownership.
• palette_finish: native report/evidence frozen: 13 creation oracle commands and 19 separate recovery checks pass. Now owns new crates/oa-cli for local source check/lint, preview/explicit-write stabilization and alias rename/diff. Uses existing source-file diagnostics/expectations/journal writer, no grammar or core changes. Root owns workspace/lock integration; serialize Cargo with release_audit. Preview UUIDs remain candidates until that invocation writes.
• Separate host Codex-956atf: standalone scenario lifetime projection, independent native scenario oracle, quantity/calculation design and library design. It has its own cold toolchain/results. Its source-only reviews are not local passes.

Verified bundles for eb5161b and 4ecad78 are retained in .local/integration-20260910. Local refs codex/behavior-snapshot-eb5161b and codex/history-seed-20260910 preserve exact commits. B4 lifetime projection and its guide delta are not integrated yet; coordinate shared scene wiring. Review found insertion versus lifetime bounds, activation after branch-local Delete and unassigned-lane map differences that must be addressed before acceptance.

Unresolved requirements and gates

1. Finish native basic supplementary move/camera/focus/minimum matrix and current scenario/process/state tasks. Main basic/transition/history/reopen passed at wide size. Check raw drafts, recovery, exact source and real task completion.
2. Implement/review/natively verify contextual missing-source and first-action flows. Named creation/history/reopen passed; operand-editing and qualified Action allocation remain separate open work.
3. Constraints/calculations and quantity compatibility are currently descriptive metadata; same-project includes are not maintained cross-project libraries. Independent semantic designs and falsification are active before broad schema changes. See library review brief. Other-host proposals expose cosmetic package revision/type compatibility, subjectless analysis closure and text-only instance normalization decisions; full reports and paired criticism are now available from verified c6d296a. Its 218-assertion maintenance experiment supports explicit baseline values with one-level Case overrides; complete freeze and effective-case evaluation are required. Refined baseline/library contracts remain active externally.
4. Implement and evaluate the source-only CLI baseline, then compare language improvements using both local usability and complete other-host proposals. Current grammar+tooling, domain syntax, namespaces and portable identity modules remain distinct candidates. Concise examples/CLI alone do not prove uncluttered modular engineering authoring or safe large-model changes.
5. Run coherent current desktop/core/server, specification, examples, REST and optimized packaging gates after integration. Prior passes remain scoped.
6. Current Linux runtime requires a viable environment: supported WSL2 import failed once with HCS_E_HYPERV_NOT_INSTALLED; no distro registered. The user has a pending environment question. No repeated denied QEMU workaround.
7. Fresh independent cross-disciplinary release review remains required after actual workflow and semantic acceptance, with all material findings resolved.

Handoff and publication

Use Gitea issue #1 and current Wiki to coordinate as Codex-9e8r6t. Read before resuming; preserve the other host's work. Direct Git push now fails authentication; anonymous fetch and Gitea MCP still work. Integration3978bbe was published and independently fetched/hash-verified as a Git bundle on codex/integration-transfer-20260910; Wiki Integration3978bbe and issue#97 own exact transfer instructions. Other host has integrated it and an equivalent Sensor fix. Creation4bb4aaf was likewise published on codex/integration-transfer-20260911, file harness/transfers/creation-4bb4aaf.bundle.b64: decoded105022 bytes, SHA256 0DEFAE91A56430076C432758F923BC0675911DA9FA7588C9961FF15F47EAEBF6, prerequisite3978bbe. Anonymous Git readback, strict base64 length/hash check and git bundle verify passed; issue#128 gives selective integration instructions. Publish subsequent corrected oracle/native/default evidence similarly; preserve the other host's later B4/reference chooser/design work and avoid duplicates.

Other-host c6d296a transfer is verified and imported as local codex/behavior-snapshot-c6d296a: 334830 bytes, SHA256 526A80E2D32ED0E57A7B2372B5F02D4652E8751DFEBA81953C4F045225D6AACB, prerequisite1797516, from codex/behavior-transfer-20260910 file harness/transfers/behavior-c6d296a.bundle.b64. Selected analysis/library/text reports, criticism, experiments and independent scenario oracle are restored; 51 evidence files compare byte-for-byte with Git blobs. No source/ledger merge. Issue#136/#143 and refreshed Wiki Authoring20260911 record the handoff.

The old ledgers, including all historical platform and native evidence, were archived byte-for-byte before this consolidation in history/2026-09-10-ledgers-before-second-consolidation, with hashes.json. Their historical-current wording does not supersede this file.