Files
ARCADIA-Studio/harness/experiments/source-alias-rename-native-20260912/review.md
T

2.4 KiB

Independent archive review

Reviewer: Codex-9e8r6t /root/native_archive. Reviewed 2026-09-12. PASS for archival integrity and claim scope; this is not native acceptance.

Reviewed archive: source-rename-native-attempt-6-20260912.zip

  • SHA256: 77adda5a33eb1def6dab23352ca0ab172300ea65fc21d2c215d545d7fcce0d08
  • ZIP size: 3,221,627 bytes; 284 unique members.
  • ZIP CRC check passed. Exact manifest membership and all 283 payload byte lengths/SHA256 values passed; PAYLOAD-MANIFEST.json correctly excludes itself.
  • All 59 original JPEGs and 47 metadata files match the original trial directory byte-for-byte, with exact membership.
  • All six physical fixture trees match the preauthored fixture manifest: simple baseline/expected/work contain four files each; representative baseline/expected/work contain 37 each. Simple work matches expected; representative work remains baseline. Physical support files are retained.
  • All five saved-disk verification receipts report exit 0, no failure, exact physical-byte match and unchanged-by-oracle. Their expected variants, four-file maps, pinned oracle/DLL/binary hashes, and stdout/stderr hashes agree with the archived evidence. Their logs report exact model/identity/four reachable sources and four exact disk files.
  • Closure receipt binds PID 9108, exit 0, unchanged binary/runtime and SHA256 values of both empty raw logs.
  • Historical launcher SHA256 cf65065d18c110a029ec4dc6bbf712cfedc0b9970992b42cb158e676a289b343 verified. Comparison to the current launcher shows only the later profile/Desktop mkdir-list entry; the archive accurately describes the historical helper as a hash-proved reconstruction.

INDEX.md and SUMMARY.json explicitly identify the minimum-size preview clipping failure and partial native outcome. They do not claim representative native rename, immediate Undo Rename acceptance, unsaved-memory inspection by disk oracles, or acceptance of a later repair. The saved Undo/Redo evidence concerns model Undo/Redo with subsequent saved-disk checks.

No executable, DLL, private-profile directory or cache payload is included. External binary/source-build bindings remain separate; archived relocated helpers are not represented as portable launch instructions.

This review used read-only archive/hash/CRC comparisons, receipt inspection and comparison with original files. No Cargo, compiler, native application, oracle, GUI, network or production edit was executed. This note records that completed review without rerunning it.